Introduction
Robert Redford. The name alone conjures images of sun-drenched landscapes, piercing blue eyes, and a natural charisma that defined a generation. More than just a pretty face, Redford carved a career as a formidable actor, a visionary director, and a tireless advocate for independent filmmaking. His impact on Hollywood is undeniable, and his filmography a treasure trove of classic and critically acclaimed pictures. But with so many memorable roles, how do you distill his work down to the very best? This article attempts to do just that: a ranking of Robert Redford’s most outstanding films, considering a blend of critical acclaim, box office success, cultural impact, and the sheer power of Redford’s performance.
This ranking aims to highlight the films that best represent Redford’s talent and contribution to cinema. We’ll be considering factors like Rotten Tomatoes scores, awards recognition, box office performance, and overall cultural influence, alongside a healthy dose of personal reflection on what makes each of these films shine. Prepare to revisit some old favorites and maybe discover a Redford gem you’ve never seen before!
Ranking of Robert Redford’s Best Films
Ten: A Bridge Too Far
While not necessarily a Redford vehicle in the strictest sense, “A Bridge Too Far” features him as Major Julian Cook in this epic World War II ensemble film. This star-studded film details the ill-fated Operation Market Garden. While ambitious in scale, and certainly featuring an impressive cast, the film’s massive scope sometimes dilutes the individual performances. Redford’s turn is memorable, injecting a dose of steely resolve into the chaos, but it isn’t quite enough to elevate the film into the highest echelon of his work. His presence is felt, but the narrative doesn’t give him enough space to truly command the scene, thus placing it lower on this list.
Nine: The Great Gatsby
Redford embodied the enigmatic Jay Gatsby in this lavish adaptation of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s classic novel. The opulent sets and costumes are undeniably impressive, capturing the roaring twenties’ extravagance. Redford certainly looks the part, bringing a quiet intensity and vulnerability to the iconic character. However, some critics felt the film lacked the emotional depth and complexity of the source material. While Redford’s performance is solid, the film ultimately struggles to fully capture the novel’s essence, preventing it from reaching its full potential and placing it lower on this ranking.
Eight: Indecent Proposal
“Indecent Proposal” is a provocative film with a somewhat controversial premise. Redford plays John Gage, a billionaire who offers a married couple one million dollars for a night with the wife. While the film sparked considerable debate about morality and relationships, Redford’s charismatic performance as the wealthy, tempting stranger is compelling. He infuses the character with a certain vulnerability, making him more than just a one-dimensional villain. Still, the film’s plot is ultimately somewhat predictable, and its impact on Redford’s career isn’t as significant as some of his other works.
Seven: Havana
Set against the backdrop of the Cuban Revolution, “Havana” casts Redford as Jack Weil, a professional gambler who gets caught up in the political turmoil. While the film attempts to evoke the same romantic and adventurous spirit as “Casablanca,” it ultimately falls short of that cinematic masterpiece. However, Redford’s performance is captivating. He embodies the cynical yet ultimately idealistic gambler, giving the film some much-needed heart. Though not a massive box-office success, “Havana” remains a testament to Redford’s ability to carry a film, even when the script isn’t perfect.
Six: The Natural
In “The Natural,” Redford plays Roy Hobbs, a gifted baseball player who gets a second chance at his dream. This sports drama is steeped in nostalgia and features some stunning visuals. Redford perfectly embodies the hope and resilience of Hobbs. The film is a feel-good story with a strong sense of American mythology. It resonates with audiences due to its themes of perseverance and chasing dreams. While somewhat sentimental, “The Natural” remains a beloved entry in Redford’s filmography and a testament to his versatility.
Five: Out of Africa
“Out of Africa” is a sweeping romantic drama set in colonial Kenya. While Meryl Streep is undoubtedly the star of the film, Redford delivers a strong supporting performance as Denys Finch Hatton, her adventurous and free-spirited lover. Redford brings a sense of effortless charm and mystery to the role. He also adds to the film’s overall sense of romance and adventure. “Out of Africa” is a visually stunning and emotionally resonant film that showcases Redford’s ability to shine, even alongside other acting giants.
Four: Three Days of the Condor
This gripping thriller sees Redford as Joe Turner, a CIA researcher who finds himself on the run after his colleagues are murdered. “Three Days of the Condor” is a tense and suspenseful film that keeps viewers on the edge of their seats. Redford portrays Turner with a believable mix of intelligence, fear, and determination. The film is a masterclass in suspense and features a compelling performance from Redford, solidifying his reputation as a leading man in the thriller genre.
Three: Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
This iconic Western solidified Redford’s status as a major movie star. He plays the Sundance Kid alongside Paul Newman’s Butch Cassidy. The duo delivers a charming and unforgettable performance. “Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid” is a classic of the genre. It’s a story of friendship, adventure, and rebellion. The on-screen chemistry between Redford and Newman is palpable, making this film an absolute must-see. This film marked a major turning point in Redford’s career, demonstrating his ability to command the screen with both charm and grit.
Two: The Sting
Reuniting Redford with Paul Newman, “The Sting” is a dazzling and intricate con artist film that won a slew of Academy Awards, including Best Picture. Redford plays Johnny Hooker, a young grifter who teams up with Newman’s Henry Gondorff to take down a powerful gangster. Redford brings a youthful energy and vulnerability to the role, complementing Newman’s seasoned confidence. “The Sting” is a clever, stylish, and endlessly entertaining film that showcases Redford’s versatility and star power. The intricate plot and captivating performances solidify its place as a true cinematic gem.
Number One: All the President’s Men
“All the President’s Men” isn’t just Robert Redford’s best film; it’s a landmark in American cinema. Redford stars as Bob Woodward, one half of the Washington Post reporting team that uncovered the Watergate scandal. The film is a gripping and meticulously detailed account of the investigation. Redford is able to bring an intense focus and a quiet determination to the role. It shows the importance of investigative journalism. “All the President’s Men” is a powerful and important film that cemented Redford’s legacy as an actor and a filmmaker. The film’s impact on political awareness and the public’s understanding of journalism remains profound to this day. His performance showcases his dedication to intelligent, meaningful storytelling, making it the definitive choice for the number one spot. The film is a testament to the power of truth and the importance of holding power accountable.
Honorable Mentions
Several other films deserve a mention for showcasing different facets of Redford’s talent. “The Candidate” offers a sharp and cynical look at American politics. “Jeremiah Johnson” sees Redford as a mountain man in a visually stunning and introspective Western. Lastly, “Quiz Show,” which Redford directed, explores the dark side of television and the allure of fame.
Redford’s Lasting Influence on Cinema
Beyond his acting roles, Robert Redford’s impact on cinema is immeasurable. His directorial efforts, starting with “Ordinary People,” demonstrated a sensitivity and skill behind the camera that earned him critical acclaim. Perhaps his most significant contribution is the creation of the Sundance Institute. This has nurtured countless independent filmmakers and reshaped the landscape of American cinema. Redford is more than just a star; he’s a force for creativity and innovation. He’s a champion of storytelling and a true visionary who has left an indelible mark on the world of film. His commitment to fostering new talent ensures his influence will be felt for generations to come.
Conclusion: A Legacy of Excellence
Robert Redford’s best films, from the con artistry of “The Sting” to the investigative grit of “All the President’s Men,” showcase a career defined by talent, charisma, and a commitment to quality. These films are not only entertaining but also thought-provoking, reflecting the social and political landscape of their time. Redford’s impact extends far beyond his on-screen presence, making him a true icon of American cinema. As you revisit these classics, consider the lasting legacy of Robert Redford: a legacy of talent, vision, and a dedication to the art of storytelling. He is a reminder that movies can entertain, inspire, and change the world.
